Healthcare Reform that Actually Works

August 20, 2009

Health care reform that actually works!

By William Tate

“Where’s the Republican plan?”

It’s one of the red herrings that apologists for Obamacare pull out of their bag of clichéd talking points when pressed to justify Democrats’ attempt to grab control of 18% of the nation’s economy.

Well, here’s a modest proposal. Rather than looking to Massachusetts or Tennessee for examples of health care reform, why not look to Texas?

The Lone Stare state has its problems, but in recent years it has made major progress in improving health care availability, especially in predominantly poor and minority regions. Being Texas, the solution wasn’t budget-busting, either.

Their answer? They got rid of the lawyers.

Not literally. But they did take on that perennial pillar of the Democrat Party, the trial lawyers.

In an Op-Ed published in the San Francisco Examiner earlier this month, Texas Governor Perry points out that in 2003 the state implemented laws that shielded health care providers from trial lawyers “anxious to make a quick buck.”

“We capped noneconomic damages at $250,000 per defendant, or up to $750,000 per incident, while placing no cap on more easily determined economic damages, such as lost wages or costs of medical care due to injury.

“We ended the practice of allowing baseless but expensive lawsuits to drag on indefinitely, requiring plaintiffs to provide expert witness reports to support their claims within four months of filing suit or drop the case…

“Changes were seen immediately, and continue to be felt. All major liability insurers cut their rates upon passage of our reforms, with most of those cuts ranging in the double-digits. More than 10 new insurance carriers entered the Texas market, increasing competition and further lowering costs.

“As a result, Texas doctors have seen their insurance rates decline by an average of 27 percent.

“The number of doctors applying to practice medicine in Texas has skyrocketed by 57 percent.”

At a time when a debate rages over whether the U.S. has enough doctors, Texas has seen its number of doctors leap by about 15,000. And Perry points out that tort reform has brought service to critically underserved, predominantly minority and poor communities.

“The number of obstetricians practicing in rural Texas is up by 27 percent, and 12 counties that previously had no obstetricians now have at least one. The statistics show major gains in fields like orthopedic surgery, pediatrics, neurosurgery and emergency medicine.

The Rio Grande Valley has seen an 18 percent growth in applications to practice medicine, adding about 200 doctors to this critically underserved area.”

According to state Representative Joe Nixon, many of Texas’ news physicians have moved to rural or underserved areas, and “Texas, once listed as 47th worst state in the ratio of doctors per citizen, will soon be in the lower 30s and improving.”

Perry says Tex as tort reform has had other benefits to patients:

“And what about the money that used to go to defending all those frivolous lawsuits? You can find it in budgets for upgraded equipment, expanded emergency rooms, patient safety programs and improved primary and charity care.”

Further, according to the Texas Academy of Family Physicians, tort reform has resulted in an improvement in the quality of health care in Texas, with the percentage of complaints about medical care actually going down.

Yet, despite the striking evidence of tort reform benefits in the nation’s second most populous state, this simple, basic and essential component of health care reform is completely missing from all Democrat proposals.

According to, Democrats received over $178,000,000 from lawyers’ donations during the 2008 election cycle — three times what they donated to Republicans. Over $43,000,000 of that went to the Obama campaign.

Forty-three million reasons why Obamacare doesn’t include the one component of health care reform that has been proven to work: tort reform.



Being only about healthcare, the columnist doesn’t also review how this tort reform, as well as a sensible regulatory and tax climate, allowed Texas to create more jobs in 2008 THAN THE OTHER 49 STATES — COMBINED.

CA is very similar to TX – border state, large immigrant population with English as a second language. Yet TX has a budget surplus and huge job creation, while CA is bankrupt and destroying jobs faster than any other economy in the known universe. All that has to be done: Import TX tax and regulatory reform. Presto – CA is a viable state again.

In the event you may be unaware: Austin, TX is the new Silicon Valley. ALL chip design done in the US at this time is done in Austin. Its high-tech hub is growing even faster than CA’s is shrinking – and no one goes to CA to start-up a high-tech business any longer. It’s all Gone To Texas – GTT (Just like in the mid-19th Century Wanted Posters…) About 15-20 companies annually move to TX… many from CA.

It isn’t rocket science – and it isn’t government interference. Get the government out of the way and market capitalism can create the wealth necessary to raise everyone’s standard of living, as well as to aid those in need.

Here’s a question for Democrats: Once Obama and Pelosi have socialized our economy, from where will the money come to provide the social programs you like? If you look around the world, all socialist economies – even socialist-lite (Europe) are far poorer than America. And getting poorer with each passing year.

About Alex Scipio

About Alex Scipio: Alex moved out of the People's Republic of California to the Free State of Arizona, finally tiring of the lack of the Bill of Rights, the overgrown idiocracy, and the catering to non-Americans & welfare recipients. He still wonders how America got from Truman, Eisenhower, and Daniel Patrick Moynihan to the Liberal and Conservative extremes so badly managing America today. And, yes, islam DOES need to be annihilated. And doing what he can to get folks away from the extremes of political life.
This entry was posted in Domestic, Healthcare. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *